Anthony Volpe Making Another Error in Game Against Blue Jays Has Fans Losing It: “Biggest Bust in Yankees History”
Anthony Volpe committed his 12th error, the most in the American League this season, against the Toronto Blue Jays, which led to a 4-1 New York Yankees loss.

Anthony Volpe (Image via Imago)
🔍 Explore this post with:
Anthony Volpe is once again at the end of receiving heavy criticism from the New York Yankees fans. The shortstop made a critical error once again on the field which led to the team losing against the Toronto Blue Jays for a 5th game in a row.
The 24-year-old has struggled with his defensive game this year. He was the talking point for the Yankees a few days back as he had his first multi-homer game in his team’s 12-9 win against the Atlanta Braves.
His defensive abilities are something that is causing fans to lose their minds. The 2023 Gold Glove winner made another throwing error in the fifth inning on Monday night.
The Yankees were leading the game 1-0 while entering the 5th inning. The Blue Jays would manage to turn the game around and lead 2-1. With a runner on base and two outs, the Yankees collapsed defensively once again.
First, Oswaldo Peraza made a throwing error. The third baseman’s throw would go past Paul Goldschmidt at 1st base, allowing the Blue Jays to make it a 3-1 ballgame.
Volpe would then have a similar error. A bad throw from him would lead to Goldschmidt fumbling the ball and allowing Myles Straw to score from 2nd base to extend the team’s lead to 4-1. As for Volpe, this was the 12th error he made this year, the most by a player in the American League.
Another error, this time by Volpe, and the Blue Jays get another run, 4-1 pic.twitter.com/FwsD5mxMlB
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) July 22, 2025
The Blue Jays would hold on to the lead and win 4-1. Earlier this month, the team had swept the Yankees in a historic 4-game series and took over possession of first place in the American League East.
With their 5th successive win against the Yankees, the Blue Jays now have a 4-game lead at the top of the standings. This 4-game deficit is the largest gap the Bronx Bombers have had for the top spot since 2023.
Yankees are 4 games back of first place in the AL East, their largest deficit since the end of the 2023 season pic.twitter.com/jbY89qHYvu
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) July 22, 2025
Social media reacts to Anthony Volpe’s error against Blue Jays
The New York Yankees ended up losing once again due to some poor defensive plays. On Monday, they once again committed some errors in the fifth inning of a game, with Anthony Volpe being one of them.

Fans on social media were left fuming with the defensive performance from the Yankees in this game. Many fans would slam Volpe for his mistakes and vent their frustration against him. One user wrote, “Biggest bust in Yankees history” while taking a swipe at the shortstop.
Check out that and some other reactions from X below:
Volpe is the biggest BUST in Yankees history
— miguel (@livefromtheshxd) July 22, 2025
Never seen a more hateable team than this year's #Yankees
— Charlie Ricker (@CharlieRicker24) July 22, 2025
I don’t understand the inability of this entire generation of Yankee infielders to throw the ball to first. I just don’t remember this being such a challenge in the Jeter/A-Rod era.
— Garrison Moratto (@GarrisonMoratto) July 22, 2025
At this point, just trade Volpe for a bag of potato chips
— JG Trades (@jg_trading) July 22, 2025
Going from this to Oswald Peraza and Anthony Volpe 🥀 pic.twitter.com/YqimjB1q58
— ⚡️ (@yankeesvision) July 22, 2025
Anthony Volpe if he didn’t meet Derek Jeter
— Josh P (@josh29parsons) July 22, 2025
pic.twitter.com/avbHS5oaXO
And they still give him too much playing time
— Maria M..Sports Fanatic ❤️ (@MariaM242598) July 22, 2025
But he’s elite… don’t you listen to Boone…. 🤦🏻♂️
— Matt Castillo (@mitchyfresh1400) July 22, 2025
Remember how badly Yankee fans wanted IKF replaced?
— Sam11LA (@Sam11La) July 22, 2025
BE CAREFUL WHAT WE WISH FOR
Top shortstop in what world?
— Roman Anthony Enjoyer (@AnthonyEnjoyer_) July 22, 2025
This is not the first time that Volpe has been under fire from the fans this season. In the game against the Los Angeles Angels last month, he would make an error with the game tied, bases loaded and one out.
In what could have been a routine double play, it led to a huge run for the Angels, which turned out to be the main difference later on. That loss turned out to be the Yankees’ 6th successive loss, leading to many urging the team to bench him.
Aaron Boone comes into defense of Anthony Volpe following 4-1 loss against Blue Jays
Anthony Volpe found himself in hot water as he committed another huge error on Monday against the Toronto Blue Jays. Amid criticism regarding his plays, manager Aaron Boone came to his defense.

The Yankees manager backed Volpe and expressed that he is still a top shortstop despite the amount of errors he has made this season.
Yeah, I mean, we’re talking about a few extra errors. That’s the separator of when he wins a gold glove and when he’s not. He’s still a top shortstop… He just hasn’t been as consistent as he has in his first two years.
Aaron Boone told the reporters
Aaron Boone says "a few plays" have created the negative narrative around Anthony Volpe's defense this season
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) July 22, 2025
"He's still a top shortstop." pic.twitter.com/VlikpajatS
Volpe would win the Gold Glove for the shortstop position in his debut season with the Yankees in 2023. In his first year, he made just 17 errors through 157 games and had 357 assists and 63 double plays. This year, he has already made 12 errors in 99 games while having 207 assists and 44 double plays.
Also Read:
- MLB Insider Drops HILARIOUS 3-Word Reaction After Brent Rooker Calls Him Out
- Derek Jeter Picking Yankees to Win 2025 World Series over Cubs Has Fans Trolling Him: “As Clueless as They Come”