“Dumbest Decision in History!” – Fans Lash Out at ‘Incompetent’ ICC for Pre-Seeding the Super Eight Teams in T20 World Cup

Interestingly, the ICC used pre-seeding during the 2024 T20 World Cup, strategically scheduling India’s matches to align with viewership timings.

“Dumbest Decision in History!” – Fans Lash Out at ‘Incompetent’ ICC for Pre-Seeding the Super Eight Teams in T20 World Cup

The ICC used a pre-seeding formula for the 2026 T20 World Cup. (via X)

In Short
  • Fans criticize ICC for pre-seeding Super Eight teams in the T20 World Cup.
  • All four group winners are placed in the same Super Eight group, raising fairness concerns.
  • The pre-seeding system is seen as a move for revenue generation rather than competitive balance.

Fans have been debating over the ICC’s pre-seeding formula, which was used to determine the composition of the two Super Eight groups at the 2026 T20 World Cup. The schedule for the Super Eight matches has been finalized, even though the last group-stage game is yet to take place.

The ICC determined the Super Eight groups, even before the tournament began this month. New Zealand and Pakistan will face off in the first Super Eight fixture on February 8. It will be followed by a double-header on February 22, with England set to take on Sri Lanka, while India will face South Africa. Zimbabwe and the West Indies are the two other teams that have made it through to the second round of the tournament. 

Super Eight groups A and B, were set in place by a pre-seeding system, in order to manage logistics and enable planning for fans, broadcasters, and organizers. Moreover, Pakistan’s refusal to travel to India for the World Cup matches due to security concerns is said to have influenced the system. As a result of this system, co-hosts India and Sri Lanka were pre-designated as X1 and Y4, respectively, and assigned to different groups.

Meanwhile, teams were also assigned seeds based on position in the ICC T20I rankings, irrespective of whether they finished first or second in their preliminary groups. For example, in Group A, defending champions India were pre-designated as A1, followed by Pakistan as A2. Australia (B1), England (C1), and New Zealand (D1) were also locked for the top spots, while Sri Lanka (B2), West Indies (C2) and South Africa (D2) followed.

While seven out of the eight predicted teams have made it through to the Super Eight stages, Australia finished as the only exception, despite being pre-seeded as X2. They were eliminated by Zimbabwe, who now occupy the X2 slot.

The asymmetrical nature of the pre-seeding system however, has placed all four group-stage winners (India, Zimbabwe, South Africa, and West Indies) into Group 1, raising concerns about the fairness and competitiveness.

It also means that two of the best-performing sides will end up getting knocked out of the Super Eights. While the pre-seeding system has come as a boon to the organizers, there is a possibility that it might significantly reduce the unpredictability of the T20 World Cup.

‘Lopsided’ T20 World Cup Super Eight groups: Cricket fans fume over ICC’s pre-seeding rule

With all four table-toppers placed in the same Super Eight group, the resulting imbalance is too big to ignore, with fans lashing out at the ICC’s pre-seeding system. Many have speculated that the ICC’s pre-seeding decision was motivated solely by revenue generation.

Fans slams ICC
Fans slammed the ICC for the T20 World Cup Super Eight groups. (via NDTV Sports)

As per the pre-seeded Super Eight groups, teams that have performed strongly through the first round will now have to play against multiple other group winners, which reduces their chances of an easy path to the semi-finals. While Group 1, with India, South Africa, West Indies, and Zimbabwe, seems competitive, Group 2, with Sri Lanka, Pakistan, New Zealand, and England, seems relatively behind.

Fans exclaimed that this pre-seeding rule signals the ICC’s incompetence. One fan strongly suggested that whoever decided upon this new system should not be allowed to make ICC rules in the future, while labeling the decision as ‘dumb’. Other fans suggested that the pre-seeding system was only implemented to benefit the Indian team, as more matches in Sri Lanka would have resulted in revenue losses.

One fan highlighted that India plays the final Super Eight stage match against the West Indies. The fan suggested that having the last match would give the Indian team an advantage to play strategically as needed, especially if qualification were to be decided by the net run-rate.

Read More: