“Stop calling Tiger Woods the GOAT,” LIV and PGA fans get into a squabble on GOAT debate between Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods

The ongoing debate between Tiger Woods and Jack Nicklaus for the title of GOAT in golf, and why Nicklaus' record of 18 Major Championships makes him a fan favorite.

“Stop calling Tiger Woods the GOAT,” LIV and PGA fans get into a squabble on GOAT debate between Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods

Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods ( Image via Sports Illustrated )

The discourse on the crown of the Greatest of All Time (GOAT) in golf has been enduring for a considerable time. However, recently, the argument has intensified after LIV Golf Nation.

The social media platform, posted a contentious statement, “Stop calling Tiger Woods the GOAT,” asserting that the golfing titan, Tiger Woods, is undeserving of the title of the GOAT, given that he does not hold the record for the most Major Championships. This controversial post incited a heated debate between Tiger Woods’ ardent fans and Jack Nicklaus’ zealous supporters.


Undeniably, Tiger Woods is a colossal figure in the realm of golf, with a spectacular career record that encompasses 15 Major Championships, 11 runner-ups, and an assortment of accolades. Woods’ ascension to glory began in the late 1990s and early 2000s when he seized his inaugural Major Championship, the Masters, in 1997.

Subsequently, Woods continued to assert his dominance over the sport in the ensuing years, winning an unprecedented four more Major Championships consecutively, and unequivocally establishing himself as one of the finest players of his generation.

In contrast, Jack Nicklaus, another luminary in the golfing universe, is revered as one of the all-time greats, with a staggering record of 18 Major Championships, 19 runner-ups, and a plethora of other achievements.


Nicklaus claimed his maiden Major Championship in 1962 and sustained his phenomenal level of play for over two decades, accumulating a remarkable list of accolades and accomplishments throughout his illustrious career. His exceptional consistency and longevity have earned him a legion of admirers and made him an eminently deserving contender for the title of the GOAT.

Related: 87th Masters champion Jon Rahm shines at RBC Heritage with three straight birdies in round 3

Why Jack Nicklaus deserves the GOAT title

Jack Nicklaus
Jack Nicklaus ( Image via CAknowledge )

Notwithstanding Tiger Woods’ illustrious career record, many fans contend that Jack Nicklaus rightfully deserves the coveted title of the GOAT in golf. One of the primary justifications for this argument is Nicklaus’ record of 18 Major Championships, which is the most in golf history.


Nicklaus’ ability to win consistently and over an extended period, as well as his overall influence on the sport, has earned him the reverence and admiration of fans worldwide.

Moreover, Nicklaus’ performance in Major Championships was consistently outstanding, with a staggering 73 top-10 finishes and an unprecedented 19 runner-up finishes, which is an unparalleled feat in the annals of golfing history.

His remarkable performance in these high-pressure tournaments cemented his status as one of the greatest golfers of all time, and his influence on the sport has inspired countless generations of golfers.


According to LIV Golf National’s Twitter account, the debate on who deserves the title of the GOAT in golf is far from resolved. While Tiger Woods’ remarkable career record has secured his position among the all-time greats, many fans argue that Jack Nicklaus should be the rightful owner of the title of the GOAT, primarily due to his record of 18 Major Championships and his overall influence on the sport.

Regardless of who ultimately emerges as the victor in the GOAT debate, it is evident that both Tiger Woods and Jack Nicklaus have indelibly left an indelible mark on the sport of golf and will forever be remembered as legends of the game.

In case you missed it:


Remembering Tiger Woods’ historic win at the 1997 Masters tournament 26 years ago

Jim Nantz speaks out about bias claims in Phil Mickelson’s coverage at the 2023 Masters Tournament

Was this article helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!