Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s Engagement Announcement Sparks Intense Social Media Firestorm
Jazz Chisholm Jr. proposed to his girlfriend, Ahnalys Santiago, on Christmas Day under the Northern Lights in Finland.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anhalys Santiago (Image via Instagram/@_jazz3/Bleacher Report)
🔍 Explore this post with:
Jazz Chisholm Jr. had a lot to say on X on Friday. The New York Yankees star proposed to his girlfriend, Ahnalys Santiago, on Christmas under the Northern Lights in Finland. Following this, he got involved in a massive social media firestorm.
The 27-year-old would share several stories on his Instagram account while celebrating this huge moment in his life. While how they started dating is unknown, Santiago, who goes by the name Ahna Mac, was seen at Yankee Stadium last October.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. is engaged! pic.twitter.com/fsqQRzJcLB
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) December 25, 2025
In what was a celebration moment for the couple soon turned into chaos. X user @KutterIsKing, who is known for trolling players, would throw shade at Chisholm Jr. The user reposted that tweet of the second baseman with a wild claim of his fiancee being an OnlyFans model.
That is OUR girl… bro wifed up an OF model 😭😭😭 https://t.co/RawVDgFQKU
— KutterIsKing (@KutterIsKing) December 25, 2025
Following this tweet from him, the two would engage in an intense back-and-forth on X. In a now-deleted tweet, Chisholm Jr. would deny the allegations made by the user and expressed that her fiancee never did OnlyFans.
My fiancé has never done OnlyFans. But maybe your mom did check on her right quick.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. said in a now-deleted tweet
After the user brought up a screenshot, the Yankees star sarcastically urged him to subscribe to the channel and see his (Chisholm Jr.) face and put his money into his account.
My glorious King Kutter got Jazz Chisholm Jr fighting for his life the day after Christmas 😭😭 pic.twitter.com/vWxMtheJ9D
— Token Picks 🪙 (@Token_Picks) December 26, 2025
The former Miami Marlins star would later claim that he realized he was fighting with a fan page.
I just realized I’m talking to someone who has a kutter fan page I’m done
Jazz Chisholm Jr. on X
I just realized I’m talking to someone who has a kutter fan page I’m done 🤣
— Jazz Chisholm Jr (@j_chisholm3) December 26, 2025
The 2-time All-Star would later hit back at the trolls and expressed that their “words” did not affect him. He would also point out that he can troll someone just like a normal person, too.
Yall be making me feel like I’m not a normal person even in my offseason I can’t have fun on this app! Like damn I’m a normal person I can troll too and still put in the work! That’s why I’m where I’m at! Cause words don’t affect me!! I’ve been slandered from when I was broke you think now that I’m up! a little back and forth on this app cant hurt me I swear! I thought yall knew me better than that!
Jazz Chisholm Jr. on X
Yall be making me feel like I’m not a normal person even in my offseason I can’t have fun on this app! Like damn I’m a normal person I can troll too and still put in the work! That’s why I’m where I’m at! Cause words don’t affect me!! I’ve been slandered from when I was broke…
— Jazz Chisholm Jr (@j_chisholm3) December 26, 2025
Jazz Chisholm Jr. mercilessly trolled on X following intense online battle
Jazz Chisholm Jr. was caught up in an intense firestorm on Friday. The New York Yankees star did not hold back and went on to feed the trolls on X. He later found himself being mercilessly trolled by other X users.

While many of them took his side and attacked the X user for dragging his fiancee, many took shots at the way the baseball star handled the situation.
Check out some of the social media reaction regarding this development on X below:
We got @KutterIsKing absolutely frying @j_chisholm3 before the Yankees made a legit Free Agent signing
— Unbiased Mets Fan (@TheMetsX) December 26, 2025
I’m crying 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 pic.twitter.com/xsWr8pSiwV
Yk maybe Miguel Rojas wasn’t that bad after all 💀💀
— DodgerFansHaveItTheWorst🇲🇽 (@batdodger03) December 26, 2025
I’ve never seen a better ad placement in my life pic.twitter.com/gBRvcM7KuA
— Justin (@JustinMLB) December 26, 2025
Jazz i’m begging please stop https://t.co/nruB4VBy9k
— Freddie🫡 (@YankeesSzn99) December 26, 2025
Jesus Christ leave him alone Kutter 😂😭 you putting this man in a body bag. https://t.co/wNRWN56fzn
— Pete (@Clipso_) December 26, 2025
https://t.co/YlcYOaEjZc pic.twitter.com/odHtLl8Nmc
— Tyler Milliken (@tylermilliken_) December 26, 2025
You could water board me and i still wouldn’t give out the kind of info Jazz Chisholm has been talking about on here today
— Justin (@JustinMLB) December 26, 2025
“Words don’t affect me” and proceeds to write a book about said words 😭 pic.twitter.com/wMU2IjSaKD
— vids that go hard (@vidsthatgohard) December 26, 2025
You not trolling big dawg you getting yo shii fried
— Ale (@FeelLikeJT) December 26, 2025
“Words don’t affect me” clearly not bro😭😭
— Tank Evans (@Tank___Evans) December 26, 2025
At the end, Chisholm Jr. would post another video of his girlfriend being emotional about their engagement and wrote, “my favorite moment of last night” in his caption.
Yankees reported to be “open-minded” regarding possible trade of Jazz Chisholm Jr.
After joining the New York Yankees through a trade in July 2024, Jazz Chisholm Jr. had an impressive first full season in the Bronx. His performances have sparked trade rumors of him with the team reported to be “open-minded” regarding this.

Compared to some of their rivals, the Yankees have had a slow start to the current offseason. Apart from getting back Trent Grisham through the $22 million qualifying offer, the team have just re-signed some of their former players on short-term deals.
One name the team is heavily linked with is Cody Bellinger. Despite having strong interest in him, the Yankees have been unable to progress in the negotiations with him.
In the midst of this, Chisholm Jr. has drawn some interest from teams regarding a trade. As per insider Bryan Hoch, the team is “open-minded” to listen to trade proposals regarding the infielder.
Yankees GM Brian Cashman said the team is “open-minded” to trade proposals for 2B Jazz Chisholm Jr.#MLBNHotStove pic.twitter.com/7mxuoTqMlm
— MLB Network (@MLBNetwork) December 16, 2025
Chisholm Jr. had a .242/.332/.481 slash line in his first full season with the Yankees and registered career highs in home runs (31), runs scored (75), RBIs (80) and walks (58). He will enter the final year of his arbitration eligibility next year and could become a free agent after the 2026 season.
Also Read:
- NY Mets Trading 2x All-Star Jeff McNeil to Athletics Sparks WILD Reactions from Fans: “Mets Are Having a Fire Sale”
- Munetaka Murakami Signing $34 Million Deal with White Sox Leaves Fans into Frenzy: “Bro Doesn’t Want to Win”