Josh Allen “born in the wrong era” theory peddled by Booger McFarland after loss to Chiefs

Booger McFarland believes Josh Allen needs better players to overcome Patrick Mahomes and win in the postseason.


Josh Allen “born in the wrong era” theory peddled by Booger McFarland after loss to Chiefs

Josh Allen and Booger McFarland (Image via IMAGO/X)

Josh Allen lost to the Kansas City Chiefs again. In the 2023/24 season, Allen and the Buffalo Bills succumbed to a late defeat in the divisional round, and on Sunday they crashed out of the AFC championship game. It was Allen’s fourth straight defeat against Patrick Mahomes and Co. in the postseason.

ESPN’s NFL Prime Time afterward co-host Booger McFarland said Allen must be thinking about whether he was born in an era to be a quarterback. The 28-year-old has a better record (4-1) against Mahomes in the regular season, but he falls short during the business end of the season.

YouTube video

I think Josh Allen has to ask himself, ‘Was I born in the wrong era?’ [That’s] because [Patrick] Mahomes is not going anywhere… At some point, [the Bills] gotta figure out a way to get over the hump.

Booger McFarland said

McFarland provided an example of the Michael Jordan era in the NBA. The 2x Super Bowl winner said there were several other great players besides Jordan when he played basketball for the Chicago Bulls.

FS Video

Allen played a great game against the Chiefs, completing 64% of passes for 237 yards and 2 touchdowns. McFarland argued that he still needs weapons in the offense—an out-and-out wide receiver one. Stefon Diggs was cut, and so far the Amari Cooper gamble hasn’t worked out. If the Bills brass don’t add quality players up front, then Allen will continue to remain in Mahomes’ shadow.

Josh Allen understands it’s hard to win Super Bowls

The Bills went as underdogs at Arrowhead despite handing the Chiefs their first defeat of the 2024 season. Allen contributed 2 touchdowns and completed 67% of his passes in the week 11 win in Buffalo.

Josh Allen "born in the wrong era" theory peddled by Booger McFarland after loss to Chiefs
Josh Allen (Image via IMAGO)

A similar performance would have sufficed in the championship game but turnovers, a dropped catch, and a few questionable decisions from the referee contributed to the Bills’ defeat. After the game, Allen looked devastated by the outcome.

It’s not fun. But to be the champs, you got to beat the champs and we didn’t do it tonight.

Josh Allen said

Allen acknowledged that it’s never easy winning the big one, especially against a team that has an established winning culture.

When you’re playing a team that’s now been to three in a row, you gotta go out there and you gotta beat them. You gotta take it from them, and we didn’t do that.

Josh Allen said via Associated Press

Allen led the Bills to a franchise record 13 wins including wins against the Lions, Ravens, and Broncos. The 2x All-Pro completed 4200+ overall yards, 42 overall touchdowns, and just 6 interceptions.

Related: Jerry Jones defends his decision to hire Brian Schottenheimer as Dallas Cowboys head coach: “As big a risk you can take”