“Yep. Won’t be tuning in”- Wrestling fans incensed after The Undertaker’s reported role in legend getting replaced by his wife on WWE LFG
Reports suggest that The Undertaker's demand led to the replacement of a former Women's Champion from WWE's LFG show.

The Undertaker and Michelle McCool (via Marca)
Since WWE’s move to Netflix, the company has been putting more focus on showcasing the reality behind the scenes of WWE entertainment. As part of this effort, WWE launched WWE LFG: Legends & Future Greats, featuring legends like The Undertaker and Bubba Ray. The show’s second season was originally set to include Mickie James, but reports suggest she was replaced due to The Undertaker’s alleged involvement.
According to Fightful, some A&E sources state that The Undertaker had a condition before continuing the show. He wanted Michelle McCool to be on board as one of the coaches. It led A&E to remove Mickie James to bring in McCool as one of the coaches on the show. It was a controversial decision that has sparked a wave of criticism against Taker.
Reports suggest that The Undertaker doesn’t have any personal issues with James. Instead, his condition was simply to have McCool by his side. However, A&E’s inability to accommodate multiple female coaches ultimately led to James’ departure from the show. Notably, the former Women’s Champion had already been featured in season one, mentoring her prodigies.
A&E sources say that Undertaker was open to continuing #WWELFG IF Michelle McCool was involved – which led to her replacing Mickie James.
— Female Locker Room (@femalelroom) March 6, 2025
Fightful Select notes – this does not indicate he necessarily wanted Mickie James off the show. pic.twitter.com/fUh31EgegO
The Undertaker has been at the center of controversy in recent weeks, thanks to his comments on modern wrestling and Vince McMahon. His statement expressing immense respect for the former WWE chairman sparked backlash among fans. As criticism continues to mount, A&E’s decision on whether to bring James back to WWE LFG remains uncertain.
WWE Universe reacts to The Undertaker’s role in Mickie James’ exit from WWE LFG show
The WWE Universe has been buzzing ever since reports surfaced about The Undertaker‘s alleged involvement in Mickie James’ exit from WWE LFG. Many fans have criticized the WWE Hall of Famer, with some even vowing to stop watching the show over what they see as a political move. The backlash didn’t stop there—Michelle McCool also found herself under fire, with critics questioning her in-ring abilities.

Moreover, fans also criticized WWE LFG crew for being unable to fit two female legends on the show. From the wide spectrum of views, here are the top reactions of the fans on X:
Yep. Won’t be tuning in. I’ll catch the talent on Evolve or NXT cause wtf is that.
— Glen Coco (@ItsDaQB) March 7, 2025
Maybe I’m in the minority here, but I never really saw Michelle as a talented wrestler.
— Jordan 👾 (@MuhCarthy) March 6, 2025
God forbid they had two female legends on the show.
— Wrestle Features (@WrestleFeatures) March 6, 2025
Whats the Deadman version of "That Doesnt Work for me brother?"
— Xtina (@Charmqn2004) March 7, 2025
WWE always playing Mickie and she just keeps on coming back
— AB (@365Boss) March 6, 2025
"You can take the wrestler out of the politics"…. "But you can't take the politics out of the wrestler ". Lol
— OCTOPI 🇺🇸 (@EnigmaticOctopi) March 7, 2025
So why can’t they coach together
— Blake_Wrld10 (@Blakezwrld10) March 6, 2025
Fans have also been vocal about wanting Mickie James back as a special coach on WWE LFG, arguing that the show could have easily accommodated two female coaches. Many believe The Undertaker had a hand in pushing her out for undisclosed reasons. At the same time, some have criticized James herself for returning to WWE despite being sidelined similarly multiple times in the past.