“HES NOT GAY????”- Wrestling fans go wild after picture of 27-year-old WWE star with girlfriend goes viral
SmackDown star posts a picture with his girlfriend on the occasion of Christmas, leaving the WWE fans baffled.

Elton Prince with Austin Theory and Kit Wilson (via WWE)
WWE superstars are busy celebrating Christmas with their family and friends. During these holidays, people are sharing some pictures with their loved ones on social media. Recently, it was revealed that SmackDown star Elton Prince is dating former professional wrestler Kelly Kincaid.
Prince and Kincaid have been together for the past few years, dating back to their time in NXT. Kelly Kincaid, a former wrestler, now works as a backstage interviewer for WWE NXT on Tuesdays. Recently, a picture of the couple went viral, taking the internet by storm, especially among fans who had previously speculated about the sexuality of the Pretty Deadly member.
Nonetheless, Prince and Kincaid appear to be enjoying a happy life, as reflected in their recent photos. Meanwhile, Elton Prince is currently part of the SmackDown roster alongside his friend Kit Wilson. The duo makes occasional appearances on the blue brand, often portraying comedic characters on screen.
Kelly Kincaid & Elton Prince pic.twitter.com/eaEVdn8eIx
— tris (@beIIabuster) December 25, 2024
When Pretty Deadly debuted on SmackDown last year, it seemed WWE had big plans for the duo. However, they struggled to make an impact, which has led to a lackluster run on the brand so far. Despite this, Wilson and Prince are an impressive pair, having previously held the NXT Tag Team Championships. It will be interesting to see how their future unfolds from here.
WWE Universe reacts to the recent picture of Elton Prince and his girlfriend Kelly Kincaid
The WWE Universe was left baffled upon learning about Elton Prince’s relationship with Kelly Kincaid. Some users on X expressed confusion about the former NXT Tag Team Champion’s sexuality, while others claimed they had already known about the relationship. This revelation sparked a range of reactions from fans across social media.

Moreover, some members of the WWE Universe revealed that they thought Prince was in a relationship with his tag team partner, Kit Wilson. From a wide spectrum of views, here are the top reactions of the fans on X:
HES NOT GAY???? https://t.co/6wrhYpD6wP
— florence ★ KO GIRL (@pchaccoskevin) December 25, 2024
Am I the only one who knew this?! ? Elton was also on a straight dating show way before he started wrestling
— ?????? ✨ (@asuka_charlotte) December 26, 2024
NO AND HES A FATHER
— ❅ BELLA. OG JHEANTOR. ❅ (@bellasusos) December 25, 2024
I was quite surprised as well.
— Kween of Kiwiville (@kiwi_bride) December 25, 2024
Neither of them are
— B. || 13-2 ?? (@CC_Razer) December 25, 2024
I will think they are and they are trying their hardest to hide it
— JelloMan (@cwcujelloman) December 25, 2024
If his real voice is deep and rigid I might pass out ?
— Joey ?✨ (@wrestlin_wasabi) December 26, 2024
Furthermore, some fans began swooning over Prince after learning he has a girlfriend. A significant portion of the fanbase also expressed a desire to see a character change for the 27-year-old. Despite his career not reaching the heights some fans hoped for in wrestling, many claimed he is thriving in his personal life.
Related: “I’m on the naughty list,” Injured WWE Star reveals what he wants for Christmas