Yankees Opting Anthony Volpe to Triple-A Has Fans Losing It on Social Media: “Miracles Do Happen”
Anthony Volpe has been optioned to Triple-A by the New York Yankees following his injury rehab.
Anthony Volpe (Image via New York Post)
Anthony Volpe is going down. On Sunday, the New York Yankees opted the shortstop to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre while backing Jose Caballero in the infield role for the foreseeable future.
The 25-year-old is yet to play for the Bronx Bombers this season. He underwent surgery on his left shoulder in October last year following a serious injury. With him unavailable for selection, Caballero was entrusted with the shortstop role.
The 2023 Gold Glove winner was playing in the minor leagues on his rehab assignment and seemed to be on his way back to the team. However, now the team has opted to keep him in the Triple-A and let Caballero play as the everyday shortstop.
Yankees have optioned Anthony Volpe to the minors pic.twitter.com/ftAuYSA4RN
— Talkin' Yanks (@TalkinYanks) May 3, 2026
This development comes at a time when Caballero has been in fine form. Before the game against the Baltimore Orioles on Sunday, the 29-year-old was batting with a .333 average in his last 16 games. He had 3 home runs and 5 RBIs across this run.
Apart from that, he was strong defensively as well. He recorded a +1 out above average, which led to the Yankees backing him and choosing to go with him as the shortstop instead of replacing him with Volpe.
The Yankees are optioning Anthony Volpe to Triple-A, per @Joelsherman1.
— Just Baseball (@JustBB_Media) May 3, 2026
Volpe hit 1 home run with a .624 OPS during his 13-game rehab assignment. pic.twitter.com/Oumy8IuR5V
The defense has been a major concern for Volpe. The Manhattan-born star has struggled defensively in recent years and made some big errors, which have caused the team. He had a -6 outs above average last season, leading to many criticizing him.
Offensively, Volpe had a slash line of .212/.272/.391 with 19 home runs and 72 RBIs last season. His batting average of .212, though, was the lowest of his career.
Social media reacts to Anthony Volpe being sent down to the minor league by the Yankees
Anthony Volpe will have to wait a little longer to make his 2026 MLB debut for the New York Yankees. He was optioned to Triple-A following his injury rehab. Fans on social media went into a frenzy following this.

Several users on X threw in wild reactions to this. Some lauded the team for taking this step. One user jokingly wrote, “Miracles do happen,” while taking a swipe at the team for relying on analytics.
Check out that and some more reactions from X below:
Miracles do happen. They must be using a new AI bot in their Analytics department
— Keith D (@Abe42429) May 3, 2026
2026 YANKEES MOVING DIFFERENT!! pic.twitter.com/41cQnQzM7R
— El Oso (@SoxSuckSavant) May 3, 2026
They are not playing around this year! I’m honestly impressed pic.twitter.com/OGW9Jd3OM2
— Morisoñando (@DimeloTigre) May 3, 2026
Wow the Yankees are moving with urgency this season is this real life?
— Brady (@shagssportstalk) May 3, 2026
Not gonna lie, I didn't think they'd actually pull that off
— Amy 🧡 (@xAmy2007) May 3, 2026
No way Yankees are leaving Derek jeter Jr in AA ball pic.twitter.com/Wb0bPmSkGv
— Checking the temp (@checkingthetemp) May 4, 2026
EVERYBODY SAY THANK YOU JOSE CABALLERO
— roseanne 🥀 (@HoodieFrazier) May 3, 2026
Who are these Yankees and what have they done with Brian Cashman?
— Matt (@mattunc2003) May 3, 2026
Dumbfounded that they made the right move, let him play and build confidence, let Cabby play the position he earned and hope it lights the fire in both of them
— Ethan Lindermuth (@TheRealEthanL) May 3, 2026
CASHMAN IS COOKING pic.twitter.com/u75dM3Zsup
— Jake (@ToysJake) May 3, 2026
Speaking of the Yankees, they took down the Orioles 11-3 to improve their record to 23-11 for the season. A win on Monday would see them complete a 4-game sweep of their division rivals, who are struggling at the moment with a 15-19 record.
Aaron Boone declines a position change for Anthony Volpe after optioning him to the minor leagues
The New York Yankees have decided not to make any changes to a winning team and thus opted Anthony Volpe to the minor league. When asked whether there would be a position change for him, manager Aaron Boone declined that.

At the moment, the Yankees have top prospect George Lombard Jr., playing as the shortstop in Triple-A. With Volpe now being there, some were left questioning whether he will switch positions.
However, according to Boone, Volpe will remain a shortstop. He will not play at any other position as the team wants him ready as a shortstop.
No, he’s getting ready to play shortstop.
Aaron Boone said regarding Anthony Volpe as per Chris Kirschner
Asked Boone about this earlier and if Volpe will play other positions.
— Chris Kirschner (@ChrisKirschner) May 4, 2026
“No he’s getting ready to play shortstop.” https://t.co/eEc0SNHfft
Earlier this year, the team had demoted Jasson Dominguez to the minor league. However, after Giancarlo Stanton got injured, he was called back up. Volpe could have a similar fate and earn a call-up in the future.
Also Read:
- Juan Soto Defends Carlos Mendoza and Mets’ Management Following 3-Game Sweep Against Rockies
- Dave Dombrowski Deflecting Front Office Question Irks Phillies Fans: “This Guy Is a Fraud”