Craig Counsell Calling Shohei Ohtani Rule As “Bad” Angers Fans: “This Is Just Sour Grapes”
The Shohei Ohtani rule was introduced in 2022 which allowed two-way players to remain as the hitter in the game after being removed as the pitcher.
Craig Counsell and Shohei Ohtani (Image via Chicago Sun-Times/X/@OptaSTATS)
Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell is not a fan of the Shohei Ohtani rule. Before his team’s showdown against the Los Angeles Dodgers on Friday, the 55-year-old doubled down on this take regarding the rule and called it “bad.“
The Shohei Ohtani rule was introduced in 2022 for two-way players. As per this rule, a starting pitcher who is also the designated hitter (DH) is allowed to remain in the game as a hitter even if the player is removed as the pitcher.
Under this rule, a two-way player is not counted as a pitcher. In MLB, teams are allowed to have a maximum of 13 pitchers in their 26-man roster. Due to this rule, the Dodgers are allowed to carry 14 pitchers.
At the moment, Ohtani is the only active two-way player in the MLB. So the only team benefiting from this rule is the Dodgers.
Earlier this week, Counsell found himself in the spotlight after he made a comment regarding this rule. While speaking with the reporters on Monday, he claimed that there was one team in MLB that was getting special consideration because of it.
It’s a rule to help offense more than anything. … there’s one team that’s allowed to carry basically one of both, and that he gets special consideration, which is probably the most bizarre rule … for one team.
Craig Counsell said regarding Shohei Ohtani rule on Monday
Craig Counsell doesn’t appear to be a fan of the rule where two-way players aren't counted against the 13-pitcher roster limit: “And then there’s one team that’s allowed to carry basically one of both, and that he gets special consideration. Which is probably the most bizarre… pic.twitter.com/G4XjWLDwcz
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) April 21, 2026
On Friday, Counsell commented on this matter once again. He doubled down on this take and aimed at this rule. While he claimed that his words were not directed straight at the Japanese international, he did not hesitate to call out this ruling.
It’s not a Dodger thing. It’s not an Ohtani thing. It is a bad rule.
Craig Counsell told the reporters regarding Shohei Ohtani rule
"This is not a Dodger thing. It's not an Ohtani thing. It is a bad rule."
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) April 25, 2026
Craig Counsell responds to questions about his comments on the "Ohtani Rule."
(Via: @FredoCervantes) pic.twitter.com/uHHTon8CIy
This is not, however, the first time someone has questioned Ohtani-related rules. Earlier this month, the Toronto Blue Jays once again complained about the time the reigning National League MVP receives to get ready and return to the mound after batting.
Social media reacts to Craig Counsell’s comments against the Shohei Ohtani rule
Craig Counsell made it pretty clear that he did not like the Shohei Ohtani rule. He, though, found himself under backlash for this as social media users slammed him.

Several X users raised the point that no one complained about this rule when he was with the Los Angeles Angels. Some raised questions regarding the mentality of Counsell. One user wrote, “this is just sour grapes,” while taking a shot at the Cubs manager.
Check out that and some other reactions from X below:
I'm a Cubs fan but this is just sour grapes and a bad look. Maybe farm systems should start cultivating two way players.
— Quadbk (@BrianHa65173474) April 25, 2026
Nah, you never talked like this when Shohei is a Halo about the Ohtani rule enacted 2022, let alone check with the MLBPA, Owners and commissioner when CBA was enacted last 2020 for 2 way players. Find your own 2-way player who plays DH and Lead batter, then talk.
— Lakers, feast or famine fandom (@Lakers_or_none) April 25, 2026
Maybe worry about how your old team replaced you with someone who belongs in a retirement home and hasn’t missed a beat since, Craig.
— Cookie (@CookieJoy720) April 25, 2026
Craig Counsell is a tool and doesn’t know that two-way player DH rule exists at every level of baseball. I hope the Dodgers sweep their sorry Cubby asses.
— BearFlagFan (@BearFlagFan) April 25, 2026
Was it a problem when he was in Anaheim??
— BigBodyBenz (@WASHED_44) April 25, 2026
Where was this enthusiasm when he was an Angel? It's a bad rule because he's not a Cub. Teach Bregman to pitch.
— Ryan Cates (@ryancates) April 25, 2026
It’s worth discussing yet he fails to discuss what makes it a bad rule 😂
— terry_hesticles1994 (@kyzersoulsay) April 25, 2026
Valid point. However, I can't find a video of him complaining when Ohtani was playing in the American League. He lacks integrity.
— Daniel Cruz 🇺🇦🇺🇸 (@DanielCruz23614) April 25, 2026
What a clown he is. Of course it is…
— hodl-shark (@hodl_shark) April 25, 2026
Why don’t you teach your DH how to pitch, taking advantage of this rule? 🤷🏻♂️
— Michael Gates (@MiaechlGates) April 25, 2026
While Ohtani is having a slump in his offense, his pitching has been strong this year. In 4 games, he has a 2-0 record and a 0.38 ERA. In 24 innings, he has picked up 25 strikeouts and seems to be finding his top form as a pitcher once again.
Dave Roberts not surprised by comments regarding the Shohei Ohtani rule
The Shohei Ohtani rule became a topic of discussion once again following Craig Counsell’s strong words. When asked about the attention it had received in the past couple of days, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts claimed he was not surprised by it.

In the pre-game conference, Roberts expressed that he did not take Counsell’s comments as malicious. He, however, backed his team and mentioned that it was not a Dodgers rule.
Not surprised. … I don’t think he meant it maliciously … This is a rule that’s applicable to Shohei (Ohtani), it’s not a Dodger rule. This was implemented when he was with the Angels. Not surprising because he’s a very important player.
Dave Roberts said regarding Shohei Ohtani rule
In his pregame media scrum, Dave Roberts doubled down on his comment in response to Craig Counsell and the “Ohtani Rule”:
— Adrian Medina (@AdrianMedina_16) April 25, 2026
“I don’t think he meant it maliciously…this is a rule that’s applicable to Shohei [Ohtani], it’s not a Dodger rule. This was implemented when he was with… pic.twitter.com/ihUoQgc54y
Speaking of the game between the Cubs and the Dodgers, the Cubs took the series opener 6-4 after coming back from 4-0 down at Dodger Stadium. This marked their 10th straight win, the first time the team had won 10 games in a row since the World Series-winning season in 2016.
Also Read:
- Logan Gilbert Catches Ball With Jersey in Bizarre Moment During Mariners-Athletics Game
- “Deserve to Get Booed,” Bobby Witt Jr. Drops Blunt Assessment on Fans Booing Royals After 8th Straight Loss